From: Mark Hall [m.hall@city.iqaluit.nu.ca]
Sent: Friday, February 03, 2006 11:17 AM
To: 'Theresa Rodrigue'; 'Annie Gordon'; 'Bernie McIsaac'; 'Brad Hall'; 'Bruce Trotter'; 'Carl Mclean'; 'Chris Freda'; 'Colette Spagnuolo'; 'Crystal Jones'; 'Darcy Reist'; 'Derrick Moggy'; 'Doug Sitland'; 'Earle Baddaloo'; 'Elisapee Sheutiapik'; 'Glenn Williams'; 'Gordanier Tonya'; 'I. Fremantle'; 'Imo Adla'; 'Jay Redfern'; 'Jim Little'; 'Jim Rogers'; 'John Hussey'; 'M. Bertol'; 'Nancy Gillis'; 'Nick Dennahower'; 'Philippe diPizzo'; 'Phillip Reeve'; 'Phyllis Beaulieu'; 'Steve Barnable'; 'Sylvia Taylor'; 'Brad Hall'
Cc: g.baker@city.iqaluit.nu.ca; 'John Hussey'; c.freda@city.iqaluit.nu.ca; d.reist@city.iqaluit.nu.ca; i.fremantle@city.iqaluit.nu.ca
Subject: Safe Storage of Car Batteries

 

 

 

Mr. Jim Little

Coordinator

Bill McKenzie Memorial Society

 

Dear Mr. Little

 

Thank you for your correspondence related to the shipment of batteries from the City of Iqaluit to Ports South, and in relation to your assertions I wish to advise as follows:

 

Firstly, the Council approved budget of $56,000 and not $60,000 as stated in your correspondence relates to the collection, storage, processing and shipment of Household Hazardous Waste, and not simply costs related to vehicle batteries.  The City takes seriously its responsibility to facilitate the collection and removal of these potentially dangerous materials from the Community, and in specific reference to vehicle batteries, your assertion that they pose no danger to the environment, I challenge directly, and I am supported by the stated position of the various Federal and Government Departments.

 

In respect to the numerous issues related to intake and storage of metals, I again take exception to the assertion in your correspondence that no effort is made to control metal disposal in the Landfill.  You are well aware sir, with your work with the Solid Waste Steering Advisory Committee, that not only has the Committee taken firm positions in this matter, but the City Council has petitioned for assistance and resources to provided by both Territorial and Federal levels of Government, and has yet to receive acknowledgement of our serious concerns with respect to the storage of metals within the Municipal Landfill, and the North 40, and elsewhere in the Community.

 

With respect to your assertion that that leachate control is virtually non-existant, I again challenge your generalized and erroneous contention.  The City has for several years been required to sample and report leachate flows within the Landfill to INAC, and as you are again well aware from your contact with the City and most recently during the 2006 Capital Budget Deliberation, the City has an approved $600,000 Capital Budget for this fiscal year to remediate the berm within the Landfill, engineer and build improved drainage ditches, and create improved containment capacity.

 

With respect to the Composting Project undertaken by the Society, it is important for the record that the City has fully supported this Project, through the provision of In kind support for space, storage, access and on occasion mechanical assistance, to a current estimated value in excess of $45,000, and at this time I must advise the Society that the area currently being used for the storage of organic materials, storage containers, truck, trailer etc. requires to be vacated, as (A) the in-kind support has been fully utilized and has now expired, and (B) the Composting Project is occupying and area that is subject to preparation and Capital Works, following establishment of the City’s ownership of Cell 2 within the Landfill. (Spring to Fall 2006)

 

The City, through the Committee and City Council, and in addition to the support provided by the Landfill Staff and Management of Public Works has been very supportive of the Composting Project, however economic reality and the numerous and competing priorities of the City Council, in providing a full range of Municipal Programs and Services within this Community form the opinion of the undersigned, that the City is not and should not be the financier, in what may well be a commercial viable initiative, best administered by Society, in partnership with Upper Tier Government and business.

 

Sincerely

 

Under authority of the Chief Administrative Officer

 

Mark Hall
Director of Public Works
City of
Iqaluit
tel: 867-975-8501
email:
m.hall@city.iqaluit.nu.ca

-----Original Message-----
From: Geoff Baker [mailto:G.Baker@City.Iqaluit.NU.CA]
Sent:
Monday, January 30, 2006 4:51 PM
To: Mark Hall; I. Fremantle
Subject: FW: Safe Storage of Car Batteries

 

Please see email below.

 

 

-----Original Message-----
From: The Bill Mackenzie Humanitarian Society [mailto:BMHS@nunanet.com]
Sent:
Monday, January 30, 2006 4:43 PM
To: James Noble
Cc: G.Baker@City.Iqaluit.NU.CA
Subject: Safe Storage of Car Batteries

 30 Jan 2006

 

 

Department of Environment

Government of Canada

Iqaluit Nu

Attention:James Noble

 

Dear James,

Could you provide a comment or two on the environmental risks of storing car batteries here in Iqaluit.This year the city intends to spend another $60,000 in shipping old batteries south. I realize there is an environmental benefit to this but it must be put into proper perspective. Lead is a potentially dangerous metal and keeping it contained is important and but absolutely no effort is being taken to contain or divert the lead (or other metals like mercury ) from entering the landfill via discarded electronics and old computer equipment? And I am sure you are well aware lechate controls at the landfill are virtually nonexistent.  The bulk of the $60,000 will go to a shipping company and considering our limited funds here in Iqaluit for any kind of responsible environmental initiative those funds could be much better utilized if spent right here in Iqaluit. I would like to see the batteries put on pallets, shrunk wrapped and stacked in a steel container until we can better afford the cost of shipping them south. Perhaps there are even safer and more practical storage solutions you could share with us? 

At the last meeting of the Waste Management Steering Committee I made a convincing economic but perhaps poorly presented case for expanding our composting project. I believe composting our waste food along with the biosolids from the sewage treatment plant is the first step in addressing all our waste management issues.

Now that we have established an efficient and economical home diversion and collection system for organic waste we want to inform the general public what the environmental and local benefits of composting are and to allow them to participate, on a volunteer basis in our composting project. There are currently about 100 families actively diverting their organic waste.

We need much less than what the city plans to spend on shipping the batteries out but unless we can convince them there are no environmental threats to storing the batteries as described above we will not get their support - moral of financial.

There have been so many agencies - private and government - that have offered their support that we are convinced we are on the right track. It would be such a shame not to take the next logical step towards a truly responsible waste management facility here in Iqaluit. If you would like to see the financial projections of our proposed facility and our plan for treating sewage sludge I would be happy to oblige. Please feel free to contact me at any time.

Cheerio,

Jim Little,Coordinator

The Bill Mackenzie Humanitarian Society

Phone 867-979-3261

Fax 867-979-6400

BMHS@nunanet.com